If you’re looking into care for yourself, a parent or another family member, you might wonder whether home care or a care home is the more popular choice.
The latest official figures for England show that more people were receiving regulated home care than living in care homes, among the providers that reported their figures. That gives us a useful picture of how care is being delivered, although it doesn’t tell us which option people would choose if both were available to them.
For families weighing up their options, the decision comes down to more than numbers. Here’s what the data tells us, why people choose care at home and when a care home might be the better fit.
Home care vs a care home: what’s the difference?
Both options can provide help with personal care, meals, medication and everyday activities. The main difference is where that support takes place and how it’s organised.
- Where you live: With home care, you stay in your own home and receive support there. A care home provides accommodation, care and shared facilities in one setting.
- How care is provided: Visiting carers come at agreed times, while a live-in carer lives in your home and provides support as part of an arrangement that includes regular breaks and rest. In a care home, a staff team looks after residents, with nursing care available in nursing homes.
- What you pay for: Care home fees generally cover accommodation, meals and care. With home care, you pay for the support you receive alongside your usual household expenses.
Neither option is automatically better than the other. What works well for one person might not suit someone with different care needs, health concerns or preferences.
What do the figures show?
The Department of Health and Social Care published its latest adult social care provider statistics on 3 September 2026.
In the week ending 14 August 2026, the figures showed:
- 489,732 people receiving CQC-regulated home care, based on returns from 81.2% of home care providers.
- 355,809 people living in care homes, based on returns from 91.9% of care home providers.
These figures cover providers that responded, rather than every person receiving care in England. The response rates also differ, so they shouldn’t be treated as complete national totals.
Even with those limitations, more people were receiving regulated home care than living in care homes among the providers that reported their figures.
Council data offers another perspective. The Department of Health and Social Care’s adult social care activity report for 2024-25 found that 61% of people aged 65 and over receiving long-term support from their council were supported in community settings on 31 March 2025.
Community support includes home care and other arrangements, so it doesn’t mean all these people were receiving care at home. The figures also exclude people whose care is arranged entirely privately.
Taken together, the data shows that support outside residential care plays an important part in adult social care in England. It doesn’t, however, tell us whether people actively prefer home care, whether their choice was influenced by availability or cost, or how preferences have changed over time.
Why do people choose care at home?
Surveys can give us a better idea of what people value when thinking about their options.
In a July 2021 YouGov survey commissioned by the Homecare Association, 88% of respondents aged 65 and over agreed that people would prefer to be supported at home. The survey took place during the COVID-19 pandemic, so its findings reflect attitudes at that time rather than necessarily representing views today.
Among respondents who said the pandemic had made them more likely to choose home care, the main reasons were being able to live the way they wanted (64%), having more control (54%) and maintaining relationships with family and friends (53%).
These are all things that can matter when someone needs more help in daily life.
Staying in familiar surroundings
Home is more than just a place to live. It’s where people keep their belongings, follow familiar routines and enjoy the things that make an ordinary day feel like their own.
Remaining at home can mean sleeping in your own bed, spending time in the garden or continuing to enjoy a favourite chair and a familiar neighbourhood. For someone who’s lived in the same place for years, keeping those connections can make a real difference.
That was true for Liz, who chose live-in care with Trinity Homecare rather than moving into a care home. As she explains: “I’m very independent and I didn’t want to go into a home. I wanted to stay where everything is familiar.”
Keeping in touch with family and friends
Living at home can make it easier to maintain existing relationships and routines. Friends and family can visit in a familiar setting, while someone may be able to keep seeing neighbours, visiting local places or spending time with a much-loved pet.
How practical this is will depend on the person’s mobility, transport options and the support available around them.
Having a say in everyday life
Care at home can help someone retain more control over their day. They may have greater flexibility over when they get up, what they eat and how they spend their time, with support built around their preferences.
The right care should also encourage people to do what they can for themselves, rather than taking over tasks unnecessarily.
For some people, visiting care is enough. Visits can start from 30 minutes and range from once a week to several times a day.
Others may need more regular support. With live-in care, a carefully matched carer lives in the person’s home and helps with daily routines, personal care and other agreed needs. The arrangement must also allow for the carer’s breaks and rest.
Is home care right for everyone?
The benefits of staying at home can be significant, but home care isn’t the right solution for every situation. The level of support someone needs, their living arrangements and their own preferences all matter.
A care home may be more suitable in circumstances such as these.
- Nursing care is needed around the clock. Some people need regular nursing input or medical support that is better provided in a nursing home. Others can receive nursing visits alongside home care, depending on their needs and the services available locally.
- The property isn’t suitable. Stairs, limited space or difficulties adapting the home can make it harder to provide safe and practical care. Some problems can be addressed with equipment or adaptations, but not every property can meet every need.
- Support is needed throughout the night. A live-in carer needs time to rest and can’t provide continuous waking care. Where someone needs frequent help overnight, additional staffing may be required and could make home care less practical or more expensive.
- A shared environment would be welcome. Some people enjoy having other residents around, joining group activities and having opportunities to socialise throughout the day.
It’s also important to consider how the person feels about each option. Someone who wants to remain at home may feel very differently from someone who would welcome the company and support available in a care home. When weighing up live-in care against a care home, everyday things such as routines, privacy, pets and cost often matter as much as the level of care needed.
How a care assessment helps you decide
If you’re unsure which option would work best, an assessment can help you understand what’s needed and what support might be available.
There are two main types to consider.
A council needs assessment is free and looks at how someone’s needs affect their daily life. The council considers what support could help them maintain their independence and wellbeing. If council funding may be available, a separate financial assessment can establish whether the person needs to contribute towards the cost.
A care provider’s assessment looks at how a particular service could meet those needs. It can help establish what support would involve, how often care would be needed and what the likely costs would be.
Both should take account of the person’s wishes, not just the tasks they need help with. Useful things to discuss include:
- Daily routines: what matters to the person and what they’d like to continue doing independently.
- Health and mobility: any difficulties with moving around, taking medication or managing daily activities.
- Communication: hearing, sight, language or other needs that could affect how care is delivered.
- Night-time support: whether help is needed overnight and how frequently.
- Family involvement: who the person would like involved in discussions and decisions about their care.
An assessment can also highlight whether equipment, adaptations or support from other professionals would help make living at home a realistic option.
How Trinity Homecare can help
Choosing care is a personal decision, and it can be difficult to know where to start when you’re trying to balance someone’s wishes with the support they need.
Trinity Homecare offers a free home assessment to understand the person’s circumstances, routines and preferences. This helps the team develop a personalised care plan and carefully match a carer to the individual.
Support doesn’t stop once care begins. A dedicated care manager coordinates the arrangements, reviews care as needs change and provides a point of contact for the family. Where needs are more complex, clinical oversight offers additional support to the care team.
With the person’s consent, family members can also use TrinityConnect to access care records and updates about visits.
Two of Trinity Homecare’s registered services, Trinity Homecare and Trinity Homecare (Worcester Park), are rated Outstanding overall by the Care Quality Commission.
If you’re considering care at home, speak to our team for a no-obligation conversation about your options.
Frequently asked questions
Is home care cheaper than a care home?
It depends on how much support is needed. A few hours of visiting care each week usually costs less than a full-time care home place. The cost of live-in care can be similar to, or more than, care home fees, although it can sometimes work out cheaper, for example when a couple shares one carer.
Can home care support higher levels of need?
Yes, in some circumstances. People with complex care needs can sometimes remain at home with the right combination of carers, equipment, community healthcare and clinical support.
Whether this is suitable depends on the individual’s needs, the level of staffing required and the nursing input available. Home care doesn’t automatically provide the same round-the-clock staffing as a care home, so it’s important to establish whether a safe and sustainable arrangement can be put in place.
An assessment can help clarify what’s possible and whether a care home would offer a more appropriate level of support.




